Prince Edward Island has a small insurance market, which makes comparing even more valuable. Coverage is sold by private insurers.
Every driver must carry third-party liability. Collision and comprehensive are optional unless your lender requires them. With shorter distances and a lot of seasonal traffic, your own usage matters: tell insurers honestly how far you drive and whether the car is parked outdoors.
Salt air and winter storms are hard on vehicles, so look at comprehensive coverage and the deductible you would pay for glass or weather damage. Raise the liability limit above the minimum, since the extra cost is usually small.
More: car insurance guide and all provinces.